Skip to main content

A moral dilemma

I've always had my reservations about death penalties. Not exactly convinced on their usage. Always felt that taking another life is god's realm and humans, especially those in garb of black gown sitting under a smiley oldies photo, have no business in it. But this particular issue, a severely sensitive one at that, is irking me so much that, thought of posting about it.

I am talking about the appeal raised against the capital punishment sentenced for the (erstwhile) LTTE trio. There are so many reasons, valid and humane at that, with which it can be argued as to why their death sentence should be annulled. But our shameless dirty pigs of politicians have decided to bleed the sentiment, dry out of this one too, which has already cost a poor lady's life. I dont understand how can speaking a common language and belonging to a war ravaged country, contaminated with ethnic cleansing and lead by the worst psychopath of a leader, who would make Khmer rogue guerrillas sound like kindergarten kids, make them qualify for a waiver of a crime they've committed, which has been proven beyond any doubt with authentic evidence.

Those poor guys have already spent not one, not two, but TWENTY years of their lives in prison. If there is anything worse than death, its awaiting it day after day, not knowing when the hangman's noose is going to kiss your neck. These people have undergone that torture for 2 decades of their life. The prime of their youth wasted in the shadow of death. Some might say, the delay was caused by the umpteen mercy pleas raised on their behalf. But again, its easier to be an armchair commentator than to actually live their lives. Saying all this, i do not support their motives or means and definitely not the result. They ARE terrorists, who killed not just a charismatically corrupt leader but 18 other people along with him and resulted in landslide victory leading to formation of a corrupt government. Their single act of terrorism. earned the wrath of his widow, which has now resulted in the eventual doom of their entire organisation. Had it been any other country, these three would've been long dead and might have even reborn.

By passing a resolution, recommending waiver of the death sentence, there by bowing to political pressure AND continuing the game of one up man ship with DMK, the ruling party has set such a horrible precedence, which sends shivers in me to even think of the events to follow. If belonging to the same ethnic group, speaking the same language are good enough reasons to pardon criminals, that too with state Government's endorsement...i couldnt get myself to even finish describing the absurdity of the scenario. Even before i could post this one, there is some organisation asking presidential pardon for Afzal Guru, on similar grounds.

"THILLU MULLU"la Thenga Sreenivasan solra mathiri ..."Murugaaa...intha naatta nee thaaanpaa kaapaathanum"!!!!

Comments

Ramesh said…
Brilliant post gils - one of the best written in the media, even by esteemed news organisation, on this subject. The utter shamelessness of Tamil Nadu politicians is appalling.

Your muse on the death penalty raises one of the toughest of issues. In Europe its banned. In the US, Japan and China it is pretty common. In India its rare, but still used, mainly for very heinous crimes. Yes, only God has the power to take life, but then people who commit murder have taken this on themselves and cannot take this defence any more. In the rarest of rare cases, where there is grievous murder commited, there is a case for the death penalty. In terrorist offences when madmen murder innocent people, it is hard to argue that the laws of civilisation must apply to them.
lakshmi said…
Me too against death penality. Ithu kooda paravalae, Indiala hanging thaan.. i saw oru ingleees serial "Prison Break".. athula chairla current pass panni kola pangranga! That too if it dint work properly on the day n if the person isnt dead i.e. half dead... avar fulla recover ayitu healthy aaki apuram saaga adipangalaa.... "YENNA KODUMA SIR ITHU!"
lakshmi said…
namba oorla kaada vettumbothu... goata thani adichu, theliyavechu theliyavechu vettu vangalae, athu mathiri iruku...
RS said…
Agree with thala. Depends on who we are talking of? Aana 20yrs is quite a looooooooooong period, isn't it? The reason for which they planned and executed The terror in 1991 is no longer possible, the leader who planned it is no longer alive. This trio has seen it all, and dying almost every day! I am sorry, but in a case as this, I am slightly biased with the trio....

@Lakshmi: Haven't you seen Viruthagiri? Thalaivar Vijaykanth padam?? Athula oru terrorist-a electric chairla ukkathi vechu, thalaivar pottu thaaliruvaar. (Avar athula interpol--aakum, aaaaaavvvvvvvv)!! Namaku englees serial-laam vendavey vendaam :P
Asha said…
well written gils!

me not always against death penalty, that guy languishing in a bombay jail and eating his fav food living in a highly secured prison must go first else with time his deeds would be forgotten and he would be pardoned while innocents fall victims to terrorism and then eventually terrorism and terrorists are justified.

Regarding the trio, More than the trio, what their families go through is horrible more so when one of them's child born in a jail, what that child must be going through in today's society. It was sad to see their mom and sis photo pleading for mercy.

Politics.. andha power appidi polirukku gils, nallavanga okkanda kooda andha political power avangala mathidarudu, bTW neenga seriousa endha murugava kaapatha koopdareenga?
gils said…
@thala:
nanri hai :) I have more violent and life threatening punishments for child molestors and rapists and their likes. To me..death can never be a penalty. Its the easiest of all punishments. The law which says suicide is a crime kills the same under the pretext of being legal.
gils said…
@lux:
namma oorla tubelightukkay currenta kaanum..ithula enga electric chairuku porathu!!!! evanumay saaga maataan appo :)

Goatta thanni thelichi vetraanga..manushana?? thanni thelichi vitrunaanga? :D :D
gils said…
@athivasi:

OMG OMG...u watching Viruthagiri?!!!!haiooo..gabtun fana neenga...!!!!
gils said…
@asha:

hahaha Lord Murugava thaan :) vera yaara nenachenga? :D

Popular posts from this blog

Weekend Movie Watch

Intha vaaram muzhichikitruntha timey romba kammi..so athunala neria padam paaka mudila :( Had a bunch of movies to watch..but no time :( First paatha padam...P.S I Love you. Rommmmmmmmmba naaala pending. Atlast managed to see it. Intha padatha pathi all my friends where raving about so much that apdi enna thaan irukungara curiosityla i started reading the book first. Not sure which one came first, but somehow i felt the book was more stronger in emotions than the movie. The heroine is more sad, more bubbly, more lonely, more enthusiastic in the book than compared to the movie. How much ever i love Hillary Swank, i still would bet Meg Ryan would've done wonders to this character. I felt it was tailor made for her. Coming to the story. A cute pair of hubby (Gerald "leonoidas" Butler of "300" fame) and wife(Hillary "Million$baby" Swank)- Who fight a lot and love each other a lot more. Nadichavanga perlaam podrathukulaye hubby dies. Wife is depressed and a...

உளறுதல் என் உள்ளத்தின் வேலை...

ellarum..ularen pervazhinu soobera kavidhai ezhuthi vachiteenga...titleuku apta yaaaarumay ezhuthala..hehee..so here is my ularal.. in damil, for a change.. :D :D பார்த்தாய் மகிழ்ந்தேன் சிரித்தாய் மயங்கினேன் "நீங்க"வில் "ங்க" நீங்கலாக "நீ"யென இடைவெளி குறைத்தாய் ரசித்தேன் துக்கத்தில் தோள் குடுத்தாய் பக்கத்தில் நீ இருக்க வெட்கத்தில் ஓடின துக்கங்கள் - என் தூக்கங்களுடன் உனை கண்ட வார தினங்கள் வர தினமாயின பாரா தினங்கள் பிணமாயின காத்திருந்த நேரங்களில் கடிகார முள் குத்தி ரணமான மணிக்கட்டு உன் புன்சிரிப்பில் குணமானது காலம் காலனானது நிகழ்ந்தது இறந்து போய் எதிர்கொண்டது நிகழ்ந்தது வீட்டில் சொல்வதற்குள் விளக்கிலிட்ட விட்டிலானது நம் உறவு விளக்கிக்கூற முயலுமுன் துலக்கிப்போட்ட பாத்திரமாயிற்று தொலைவு போன பொழுதிலும் தொலைந்து போன மனதில் பிளவு தான் பட்டிடுமோ - குளிர் நிலவு தான் சுட்டிடுமோ காலங்கள் மாறினாலும் காயங்கள் ஆறினாலும் காதல் தான் மாறிடுமோ கூறுங்கள் மானிடரே ROTFL...iduku mela..ennala controla panna mudila..padichu paatha sirippa varuthu...so here u go...n u all know ver...

Aayirathil oruvan

Long awaited movie. The expectations went up manifold after watching the trailors. Selvaraghavan is one of the few directors whose movies people flock to see just for his skill alone. This movie was no less. Right from the title, it sounded a magnum opus. Five minutes into the movie, you can feel that.."wow..this looks different". One thing, it didnt seem your normal tamil movie at all. More like an Indiana jones movie. I can boldly put my neck on the block and say that the first half of the movie, is something you would've never seen in entire tamil cinema history. It has THE BEST adventure sequence to have been visualised EVER in a tamil movie. I was simply amazed at that stone henge sequence and the nataraja shadow. It was simply..WOW. That one single scene has so many inbuilt sequences and logic that it was awesome. The cholas creating the hurdle in such a way that you've to be in the shadow of God (Nataraja, Chola's favourite deity) else get swallowed by bott...