Skip to main content

Of languages and communications

I saw 2 interviews which formed the basis for this post. This has been running through my mind for quite a while now and recently saw another interview which eventually resulted in writing it all up. The first interview was that of Singapore's PM Lee Kuan Yew. It was more of a snippet about his views on India. The part that grabbed my attention was how much he is surprised about India as a whole and despite all its misgivings and contradictions how it continues to surprise everyone and sets an example for the world to follow, especially with its idea of Unity in diversity. He mentioned how easy or streamlined it is for his country or countries like China/Japan or even bigger countries like Russia, where majority of the nation follows a common language and it is easy for the government to pass on their policies and ideas to their population. Whereas in a country like India, which is more of a subcontinent and more diverse than even Europe, a small region which is actually an extension of Asia, but refuses to accept that and recognizes itself as a continent. Unlike Europe where each of the different tongued regions are countries, in India they are part of the union as states. Meaning, those who come to power at the centre, are almost a continent away from the farthermost region of the nation and if at all their message needs to traverse and reach the last man standing, it has to cut across several local and regional barriers, by chance and by design, which dilutes the essence and many a times creates a 360 degree different perception of what was initially conceived to be conveyed. The SGP PM wishes India could somehow come up with a common language that will enable smoother governance while at the same time, marvels at how the nation has picked itself from the pieces left behind by centuries of loot by foreigners. As much as he marvels at the concept of diversity, considering his background, he roots for a common thread that can unite the nation stronger.

The second interview and the third one are slightly contradicting in nature when it comes to the message from the previous paragraph. One of those was that of Kantara star Rishab Shetty. That guy was so polite and courteous and respectful that, anyone would immediately start liking him. He comes across as  a calm person with an immediately likeable personality. The best part of the interview being, he spoke in tamil!! As fluently and more than the anchor!! Him being a native kannadiga the ease with which he spoke tamil made me realise the effect of learning another tongue and its impact on the native speakers. The third interview was also on similar lines, that of Shivrajkumar, Upendra and Raj shetty(?) who were on a round table discussion, fluently chatting in tamil! There is a sweetness to kannadigas as such and especially so when they speak in tamil. Be as it may that they might've spent their whole childhood, schooling and even college here in chennai and having spent almost half of their lifetime in this city, it might be hardly surprising that they are so fluent. At the same time, despite having stayed in Bangalore for close to a decade, the best kannada i could manage was "seedha hogi ..right hogi" to a tamil speaking auto driver!! It is not just the intent, the benefits it brings with, the knowledge you gain by understanding other tongues, but the respect it shows to the native people and the connect it establishes, especially for people in public domains. It makes one immediately receptive of them and the fact that they've put in effort to speak your tongue gains them respect and attention to start with. It made me realize, how much my colleagues would appreciate if i can talk to them in Hindi or telugu and how easy it would've been for those from other states if people can talk freely. Somehow, despite being the de facto language for communication all these years in IT, it doesn't feel like chatting when you talk in English. You can crack jokes, but nothing beats the effect it garners when you say even silly things in a local tongue.

Coming back to Mr. Yew's argument - yes. It definitely is a need of the hour to have a language that is far reaching and a simple medium through which the length and breadth of the nation can be brought together and if it is Hindi so be it. But it shouldn't stop anyone or be an impediment to learn other languages. Afterall and above all it is for this reason that Mera Bharat is always Mahaan, for it offers you a lot. Depends on the individual to pick it up.

Comments

Ramesh said…
With all due respect, I heartily disagree with Lee Kuan Yew. India DOES NOT need one single common language in my humble opinion.

Diversity is a massive virtue and one of India's biggest strengths. Diversity comes in many respects - langauage is just one of them. Religion, culture, food , values - they are all equally valid forms of diversity. One of the higher human values is, I submit, the ability to respect and appreciate different peoples. We lose something when we want to create clones.

Technology will soon (if not already) eliminate the need to learn multiple languages. I am severely against language nationalism. I have lived in 8 states speaking completely different languages and visited every state in India. I cannot physically learn so many langauges. It has never stopped me from appreciating every place I have been in.
gils said…
Adhunalathaan neenga epovumay thala 🙂

Popular posts from this blog

Unnnai...Kan theduthay...HIC...

LOSTnu oru serial thenamum Starmoviesla podraan...atha paathu oru smaal karpanai..namma blog makkala sila per kaanama poitanganna ad epdi varumnu...DDla kaanamal ponavar patriya arivipu mathiri...itha typitu naan kaanama poidlamnu iruken...maatina nelami konjam kavalikidamaaga ariguri neriya iruku :D G3: Kaanaamal pona andru nanraanga jeeravil mukkiya jaangiri nira sattaiyum...pon varuval coloril pantum aninthirunthaar...idathu kaiyil manapaarai muruku packetum...manja color paiyil biskothu..matrum sila pala snacksum irunthana..valakkaiyil kerala nenthranga chips oru kilopacketum..oru seepu vaazhaipazhamum irunthana...(please note...intha description bayangara dynamica change aaga kudiyathu..so if u see someone with fruits on left hand and sambar vadais on the right hand..then also..please report) Heidi: Mocha restaurantla ivanga order panna chefs delight disha kondu vantha andala kai thavari vizhunthutaanga...mocha folks are still searching for her....konjam konjama contents of the an...

Satti sutathadaa..(no offence meant to sat:) )

Padathayum titlaiyum paathutu idhu aadi maasa spl, released latenu ,thapaa thinkidaatheenga..antha sattiku pinnadi...oru peria story iruku :D last time wen had a bloggers meet in chennai mokka fwd g3,u----- heidi,billoo barani, myself and firstdream ramya all met in a restaurant suggested by the one and only heidi..mokka poda vasathiya mocha restaurant in nungambakkama select panaanga...venue selection heidina udanay billo baraniku slighta udharal...previous bloggers meetla namma heidi order panna dishesa saaptu peeeeeeeeeeeritukitu vantha ..sogam (ada nejamavay sogam thaanga :)) ninaivuku vara barani aajar aavaarangarathu kelvikuriyaa irunthichi...still medical insurance policylaam chk panitu with his will steadied...(will powera sonen...) barani made a special appearance right in time for the bill payment...now for the matter...golden rule number one for ordering any dish...Never ever try the one named chefs delight or restaurants special...sambala baaki..hike prachanai ella kadupaiy...

Enna koduma saaar ithu!!!!

We are a group of 5 who share our apartment. Usually me and one more guy are the last to the leave the house everyday morning. Yesterday, the one who used to leave first for office, didnt come home till 11. I went to sleep after the usual book reading session at around 11.30. When i woke up i saw it was only me who was still lying on the mat while even the guy who leaves for office along with me, had already started folding his bed!! I was feeling very tired and sleepy and was in two minds whether i should take off or go late. Still managed to crawl..brushed teeth half sleeping and swtiched on the geyser. I turned back to see, suddenly it was pitch dark outside the bathroom!! Since the light was On inside, it wasnt power cut and i came out to see what was wrong. The guy who folded his bed, had moved to the hall and was again asleep!! Then only i noticed, it was dark outside the balcony too!!! I checked the time. It was 3AM!!! BOOOOHOOOOOOO!!! SOB SOB SOB!!! That useless guy afterwards ...