Skip to main content

War of Lanka by Amish Tripathi – book review

Like the Meluha series, War of Lanka happens to be the fourth and final installment of the Ramachandra series. Like how he distorted Shivapuranam to his material gains and ill-gotten popularity, Amish has butchered Ramayanam in these series to the maximum extent possible. Of all the people who have been baying India is intolerant, the success of these series is a testament to the patience and mindfulness of our people. Had it been any other religious book or any other famous book for that matter, where the lead characterization is distorted to this extent and glorification accompanied by misrepresentation in the name of fictional liberty, the author might’ve found himself in a precarious position if not life threatening. This book is nothing, but trash be it for the way of misrepresenting a holy epic. If not for the religious angle, even as a regular pulp fiction it is still garbage. Of the 4 books in the series, this is the worst. There is literally no space for story with only the travel of Bharatha and shatrugana from Ayodhya to the shores of Lanka explained like T&L channel program. The other aspect covered in detail being the naval warfare, where the author thinks of himself as Tom Clancy of previous Yuga, trying to paint a picture with a zillion words, leading the story to exactly nowhere. The most irritating thing for me was how he has characterized Ravana. The very fact that he kidnapped someone’s wife forcefully which led to his downfall, despite being a shiva bakthan and possessor of several weapons and boons has been distorted to the extent that, it is mentioned that Ravana wanted the war to happen and willingly sacrificed his life and his kith & kin just to ensure Rama became the leader of India !!! Wonder what the author was smoking when the wrote these sections!! It is obvious that he ran out of stock to twist the tale for a decent ending and messed it up royally. Be it the way he had represented Hanuman with a one side love story, skipping over several key role players in Ramayana and making a mess of the entire story line by pulling Bharatha and shatrugana in the final battle, all of them make a nauseatingly sick ending. My best guess is, like how I mentioned about one of the previous books, this guy must’ve written several pages in a rampage and literally played inky-pinky-ponky in deciding how to split them into multiple portions. The sad part being that the finale portion ended up being the blandest and stupidest of the lot. I am not against taking creative liberty and producing own versions of how one perceives other famous creations. But if you try to mimic Monalisa and end up with a hangman figurine, bouquets wouldn’t be filled with flowers but rather bricks.

Comments

Ramesh said…
Gilsu is right royally pissed. If such a gentle and fair reviewer such as Gilsu is driven to such a state, it should be one of the worst books ever written. I shall delightfully ensure that I do not touch an Amish Tripathi book ever !!

Popular posts from this blog

2 phone calls and an amazing week...

Its amazing how much a voice can convey..apart from whats being said. In past 2 weeks i had 2 such conversations over phone which made me feel like...WOW!! First one was more emotional and sentimental at the same time very positive and heartwarming. The distance of several thousand kilometers was nonexistent for the entire duration of the call and even after that call it still feels the same. I am happy for the day i got introduced to "People Network" through which we made our acquaintance and me the forever greedy would pray for more such days. What began as a call to console soon turned out to be the best motivational talk i ever had. That person recounted incidents from their personal life and how they overcame it to be what they are now. It was touching and a rare gesture that i felt so happy that they were kind enough to share it with me. It immediately shook me out of my gloom and i was soon back to normal. I am indebted to that person for that call and for the support ...

From Confedration towards Confused Nation

Andru: "avvvvvvvvvvvvv.....enaku antha bommai venum..." "chellam...adam pudikathada..saapdu" "saapda maaten po..enaku antha bomma vaangithanthaa thaan sapduven" "chamthula..saapduma...amma paavamla.." "avvvvvvvvvvvvv.....maaaten maaten" "ipo sapdla..udha vizhum" "maaten...maaten..maaten" The kid ultimately prevails and the doll is bought. Indru: "Fast unto death"..."wont even drink a drop of water...till telengaana is achieved"..."blood will flow.." blah blah blah... And this time the government yields to the demand. Thottil pazhakkam sudukaadu mattumnu summava solranga. Ithuku thaan chinna vayasulaye nalla naalu kaatu kaati iruntha intha mathiri caselaam adangirukum.

Yours Lovingly.. :( final part

The 3 days went in a blur..he cudnt even recollect what he did or dint and was eagerly awaiting for Arunas call..It never came. He got tensed and tried reaching her number in vain..The weekend went in trying her number..When he went to office first thing he stopped short of sending her a stinker..he jus wrote Hi and sent a mail..no response came..finally he dared to call up her office and check..he called jaya.. "Hi jaya.." "heyyy..Ram..watta suprise..u calling me..cudnt believe it..how are u..how are things at ur end.." He controlled himself and patiently answered her.. "tell me hw cme u remembered me.." "can u tell me if Aruna is around" There was a gap before she answered in mock protest.."so..u dint mean to call me..want to know abt Aruna is it..i wnt tell u.." "pls pls..pls jaya..is she arnd? can u ask her to call me..i am unable to reach her..neither is she replyin to my mails.." "am i her PA" he could...