Skip to main content

Agatha Raisin and the potted gardener by M.C Beaton - book review

At last some shade of positivity at least in the form of book. Was really worried with the kind of content I was grazing at, be it books or movies. Thanks to mister Mages, who shared this book, which turned out to be perfect antidote. The story felt more Enid Blyton-ish in setup, flow and made a nice read. And it was a detective series as well. Probably the most naïve murder investigation I’ve ever read. But still makes up in its charm. I googled about the author and was amazed at the list of books published by her. My god!!!! She seems like a factory for churning out books. Not sure if you can classify these novels as kids section but may be bit more serious than the Nancy drew/ Hardy boys genre.

I suppose, this particular book, is somewhere midway through the series, for there are no formal introduction to the characters. Be it Agatha or the village or her crush James, everyone is being mentioned on the fly and any backstory related to them, discussed over the course of conversations as well. There is something about the way the English talk about their villages. It is not like our local ones which are mostly depicted as poor, dry or barren. The English villages are always green and there would be non-stop mention about their gardens. The people are known to be gossipy and there are so many clubs and societies where the entire community mingle. There are pubs and restaurants that are known by name to everyone on the village and fun events involve everyone in the village. A similar setup is what we get to see in this series as well.

Agatha raisin, is interestingly named. Guess, it must be as a mark of respect for the queen of thrillers and Raisin. She is not your petite young lassie, but a divorced women bordering 50 age limit. She is so much smitten by her next door neighbor, who runs away from her, whenever she tries to express her feelings, but he has no qualms in philandering with other women!! They are both partners(sic) in crime. Not in committing but on solving them. There is a smart young detective of Chinese origin who is always helpful and there are couple of other recurring characters, along with her pet cat, who make up the ensemble. In “Potted Gardner” the pace is so leisurely setup that, first 22 pages of the book talks about, Agatha’s return back to the village from some trip and what gift she had got for the village folks. There is this mysterious, cynical lady, who is so good looking that menfolk of the village are immediately smitten. She gets killed in a brutal manner, which was quite a deviation from an otherwise quiet and calm storyline. Agatha gets to find out who killed her. Basically that is the plot. But almost the entire village seems to be on suspect row, with that lady having rubbed everyone the wrong way. The investigative approach is quite straight forward- Agatha asks the person directly. No brain churning puzzles or clues. Straight as an arrow. There is a gardening competition as well, amidst all this chorus, which Agatha cheats, to beat the mystery lady, only to get caught. I thought there may be some key thing around the gardening event, for, right from the title and almost through half the book, it was being mentioned. But it turned out to be a damp squib.

Gils verdict – a new author and series to follow. Probably not the best first book to start in the series. But I love the premise. It may neither be for kids in their teens, nor be for adults. Oru rendugettan set of folks who are forever in between the gap (enna mathiri) may take a fancy for this series. Adutha book epdirukunu paapom.

Comments

Ramesh said…
Where are you discovering all these authors of detective novels - I had not heard about any of them until reading your review. Presumably "mister Mages" and your other friends have a varied reading habit.

This sounds very Enid Blytonish except that the characters may be adults. Better read than all the gory stuff out there.

What do you mean you are forever in the gap between teens and adults. Rubbish. You ARE a teen, Gilsu :)

Popular posts from this blog

Ode to the Nice Guys

This is a tribute to the nice guys. The nice guys that finish last, that never become more than friends, that endure hours of whining and bitching about what assholes guys are, while disproving the very point. This is dedicated to those guys who always provide a shoulder to lean on but restrain themselves to tentative hugs, those guys who hold open doors and give reassuring pats on the back and sit patiently outside the changing room at department stores. This is in honor of the guys that obligingly reiterate how cute/beautiful/smart/funny/sexy their female friends are at the appropriate moment, because they know most girls need that litany of support. This is in honor of the guys with open minds, with laid-back attitudes, with honest concern. This is in honor of the guys who respect a girl's every facet, from her privacy to her theology to her clothing style. This is for the guys who escort their drunk, bewildered female friends back from parties and never take advantage once they...

Padithathil pidithathu

Few authors thrill us to read more of their creations. At times its sheer luck that we might end up with the worse of their lot and might give up on them only to find many other good ones which we would've ignored based on first impression. James Rollins is one such author. My friend's sister introduced me to "Map of Bones" and told me that its in the same genre of "Davinci Code" and since i am a sucker for adventure series she recommended this one to me, with a warning that, at times this guy goes over the board like Ludlum in describing situations. With that warning in mind i began the book. I took my own sweet time to finish it but the book kept me interested. However many times i kept it down i always went for it again to know what happened next. In the end, i pretty much liked the story, though it was totally unbelievable. The story is about the bones of the Three wise men or Magi who visited Jesus when he was a kid. Their bones held a clue to a vast so...

Hearbeat - season 2 - review

What makes a drama series tick, in OTT, that too in Tamil? The question should've been pretty straight forward and not as difficult as it is for making a successful movie, for drama series are dime a dozen across scores of TV channels and none of them are found wanting for audience. The more the cry the merrier the TRP. In that context, the only challenge that OTT platforms might've had while streaming tamil series must've been to choose the path - either the well trodden and worn out cryathons aligning with Satellite channels or try for something genre specific like how they do across English and other foreign languages. This is where Heartbeat series in Hotstar finds the fine balance between being a soap oppaari (no pun intended) in tv and carving a niche OTT audience.  While the setup might've been familiar one for Hindi audience with so many series happening on hospital based storyline, i guess this is a first for tamil. The first season was more on establishing the...